
Dear Care To Be Different,
My mum has dementia and is about to be discharged from hospital. Should the NHS fund her care at least until the Checklist for NHS Continuing Healthcare is completed?
We are often asked questions about a patient’s entitlement to CHC care funding upon discharge from hospital.
As with all things CHC, there is no quick or easy answer to this; it depends on the circumstances! Here are three common scenarios to assist you:
What is CHC?
Firstly, if you are new to CHC, here’s a quick overview:
NHS Continuing Healthcare (commonly abbreviated to ‘CHC’) is defined in the National Framework for NHS Continuing Healthcare and NHS-funded Nursing Care (July 2022) as “a package of ongoing care that is arranged and funded solely by the National Health Service (NHS) where the individual has been assessed and found to have a ‘primary health need’ as set out in this National Framework. Such care is provided to an individual aged 18 or over, to meet health and associated social care needs that have arisen as a result of disability, accident or illness…”
The Checklist is the preliminary NHS screening tool to determine whether a patient will go on to a full assessment for CHC Funding carried out by a Multi-Disciplinary Team Meeting using the Decision Support Tool. If successful, the NHS will fund all that patient’s assessed healthcare and social care needs, including the cost of their accommodation. So, an award of CHC can make a huge difference as to who funds care.
The starting principle to bear in mind is that the NHS National Framework states that, “There must be no gap in the provision of appropriate support to meet the individual’s needs.”
Taken at face value, this suggests that the NHS should continue funding a patient’s care upon discharge from hospital until the NHS CHC assessment process is complete – starting with the Checklist assessment.
Understanding The Checklist Assessment
Getting started with CHC? How does the CHECKLIST work
Can the NHS refuse to carry out an initial Checklist?
1. Discharge to Assess from hospital
Looking at the NHS National Framework (the rule book and guidance for CHC), the general rule is this:
“112. The Standing Rules require an NHS Integrated Care Board (ICB) to take reasonable steps to ensure that individuals are assessed for NHS Continuing Healthcare in all cases where it appears that there may be a need for such care. These regulations also state that if an initial screening process is used to identify where there may be a need for such care, then the Checklist is the only screening tool that can be used for this purpose. The purpose of the Checklist is to encourage proportionate assessments of eligibility so that resources are directed towards those people who are most likely to be eligible for NHS Continuing Healthcare, and to ensure that a rationale is provided for all decisions regarding eligibility.”
And:
“117. Where there may be a need for NHS Continuing Healthcare, a Checklist should normally be completed.”
So, if the patient is going from hospital into a care home or nursing home (or perhaps EMI residential) for the first time, it would be reasonable to assume that there may be a need for CHC (i.e., healthcare). In which case, Discharge to Assess (D2A) funding may be appropriate, pending completion of the Checklist, once ongoing needs are clear. Essentially, the NHS will take responsibility to continue funding a patient’s care needs upon discharge until they have been assessed in their community setting for CHC. This D2A funding could be a matter of weeks or longer if the NHS are slow to get the Checklist actioned.
Remember: The NHS National Framework guidance is that Checklists should no longer be completed in hospital settings, in all but exceptional circumstances. Therefore, the NHS might be expected to fund ongoing care until the patient’s requirements are clear, and a Checklist can be completed. Whether this happens in practice can depend on each ICB’s local arrangements and how ready the family are to argue their corner for D2A to continue.
2. Is there a Primary Health Need?
“120. Local health and social care joint processes should be in place to identify individuals for whom it may be appropriate to complete a Checklist, including for individuals in community settings. Wherever an individual requires a long-term care home placement with nursing or has significant support needs, a Checklist would be expected to be completed (unless the decision is made to go straight to the completion of a Decision Support Tool).”
However, if they are being discharged to a residential home and their care requirements are straightforward, it may be reasonable to assume that the ‘primary need’ is for social care, unless there are indicators this is not the case. In this situation, we don’t think there would be an expectation for the NHS to fund on discharge from hospital (D2A). The onus would be on the care home to submit a Checklist once the person has settled in – IF their needs may be indicative of a primary need for healthcare. If they are subsequently found eligible at the full Multi-Disciplinary Team assessment, an argument could be made that CHC Funding should be backdated to the date of admission into care.
Establishing A Primary Health Care Need
3. Has the patient been Optimised?
Now let’s consider an alternative scenario:
“118. Screening for NHS Continuing Healthcare should be at the right time and location for the individual and when the individual’s ongoing needs are clearer. This will help practitioners to correctly identify individuals who require a full assessment of eligibility for NHS Continuing Healthcare.
119. In the vast majority of cases, individuals should be screened for NHS Continuing Healthcare in a community setting. Paragraphs 101-108 set out how NHS Continuing Healthcare interacts with the hospital discharge process.”
The other possibility is that the patient needs a period of ‘reablement’ at the point of discharge – i.e., having possible therapy or treatment that might help aid their recovery first, before a decision is made as to their potential long-term funding needs. This is known as ‘optimisation’ and options could include things like physiotherapy, mental health team involvement, rationalisation of medications etc. In which case, the NHS might be expected to fund care until such a time as optimisation is achieved, and there is a clearer picture of ongoing long-term care needs. At which point, a Checklist should be completed. Again, it depends how much the family wants to/is capable of arguing with the Hospital Discharge Team and what local arrangements the ICB have in place.
Get in touch if you need help arguing for CHC Funding upon discharge from hospital.
Here’s how we can help you!
Read our free blogs
Book an appointment with our Nurse Advice Helpline for specialist advice
Join our Facebook community and get help from others with similar experiences.
Don’t miss our helpful book: “How To Get The NHS To Pay For Care” available as a paperback or PDF download
If there is a particular topic you would like us to cover, we’d love to hear from you! Just send an email via our “Contact Us” page with the subject “blog request” and we’ll do our best to cover your suggested topic.
Leave a Reply to J Rainer Cancel reply